Stepper vs. servo for linear actuators
It is the question behind half the sizing requests we see, and the honest answer depends on three numbers the engine computes for both motors at once.
Watch: the same spec sized as stepper and as servo
Two-Minute Motion #2 — a 3.5 kg, 500 mm, 250 mm/s axis sized both ways. Stepper: 764% torque margin, 214% speed margin, about 24 cycles/min. Servo: 437% torque margin, 1,446% speed margin, about 40 cycles/min, roughly $150 more per axis. Watch on YouTube · All episodes
Read the transcript
Stepper or servo? Everybody has an opinion. Let's size both and look at the numbers. Hi, I'm Jeff Doughty with ModuSystems. This is Two-Minute Motion: same spec, both motors, real torque curves. Single-axis application: 3.5 kg payload, 500 mm travel, 250 mm/s speed, horizontal orientation — stepper or servo? Let's go to the numbers. What's nice about ModuSystems AI is that it has already calculated all the important data — all the physics needed to make this decision. The torque due to acceleration, gravity and thrust has already been done. It has already run a sweep on the NEMA 17 motor family, and selected a 3:1 gearbox because the inertia mismatch was above 10:1. It has also run the calculations on move profile and throughput. Now let's go to the comparison: stepper versus servo. The stepper motor has a torque margin of 764%. The servo has a torque margin of 437%. Speed margin for the stepper is 214%; speed margin for the servo is about seven times that, at 1,446%. The stepper motor does very well at low speeds with high torque. The servo motor does very well at high speeds with high torque. The inertia mismatch is slightly different, because a servo motor has a higher rotor inertia. In terms of speed capability, max speed on the stepper is 500 millimeters per second; max speed on the servo system is 1,000 millimeters per second. That equates to approximately 24 cycles per minute for the stepper and 40 cycles per minute for the servo. The servo will run you about $150 more per axis. So you have to make a decision: what's more important, throughput or budget? It's your decision. Requirements in, real motion out — at ai.modusystems.com.
Three numbers that decide
Torque margin at speed. A stepper's available torque falls steeply with rpm (its pull-out curve); a servo's continuous torque is nearly flat. The engine reads both from catalog curves — stepper at 24 V, servo at 48 V — at the rpm your speed and pulley or lead demand, and requires at least 25% margin. Speed margin. How far the catalog speed cap sits above your request: 500 mm/s stepper versus 1,000 mm/s servo on an SBA45 is the difference between 42% and 620% headroom at a 300 mm/s spec. Inertia mismatch. Load inertia reflected to the motor over rotor inertia; above 10:1 the engine computes a gearbox remedy (3:1 or 5:1 PLE gearhead, its own inertia included).
| Stepper (NEMA 17/23/34) | Servo (NV17/23/34) | |
|---|---|---|
| Payload cap | 25 kg | 50 kg |
| Speed cap (XY) | to 1,200 mm/s | to 2,500 mm/s |
| Z speed cap | 500 mm/s | 750 mm/s |
| Behavior near limit | stalls (no feedback) — size with margin | follows with feedback; peak headroom above continuous |
| Controller | BLC-2T / 4T / 6T | BLC-2TC / 4TC |
| Price, SBA45 500 mm with 3:1 gearbox | $1,800 | $1,950 |
A worked example
2.5 kg over 500 × 500 mm at 8 cycles a minute. Stepper: SBA45, N17-1 with 3:1 gearbox, 166% torque margin, 43% speed margin, 8.2:1 inertia, 8 cycles/min at spec. Servo: SBA45, NV17-1 with 3:1, 171% torque margin, 621% speed margin, 5.2:1 inertia, 8/min at spec and 9.2/min at the catalog cap. The delta is $150 per X-axis. Both are correct; the servo buys future speed, the stepper buys price.
When the answer is obvious
Above 25 kg or 1,200 mm/s, servo is the only catalog option. Below 3 kg and 300 mm/s with no growth expected, stepper wins on cost and simplicity. In between — most real applications — the engine's two-column comparison is the fastest way to a defensible decision, and it prints the basis for either choice.
Size it yourself in about a minute
Type the task — payload, travel, speed — and the Engineering Decision Engine returns a validated, priced 3D system with the torque margins, inertia check, and cycle-time math shown. Free to design and quote.
Frequently asked
Does the engine size both motor types every time?
Ask for a comparison — "stepper or servo?" — and it sizes both columns from the same spec on real torque data and shows the price delta. Otherwise it sizes the type you specify.
What is inertia mismatch and why 10:1?
The ratio of load inertia reflected to the motor shaft over the motor's rotor inertia. Above roughly 10:1 a stepper loses positional accuracy and a servo becomes hard to tune; a gearbox reduces reflected inertia by the ratio squared.
Why 24 V for stepper and 48 V for servo?
Those are the standard supply voltages for the controller families (BLC-T and BLC-TC) the engine quotes; the torque curves are read at those voltages so the margins reflect the system as it will actually ship.